« The Economy is doing Awesome! So where's all the Press? [Back to Blog] March 8 Speaker Forum »

Nanny-State Sen. Kruger Proposes Stupidest Idea of the Year

Is it possible anyone thinks that Sen. Kruger's idea to ban the use of ipods, walkmans and cell phones while crossing the street is a good idea? Frankly, I think this is one of the stupidest, most brain dead ideas I've heard in a long time. And in NYC that is really saying a lot.

First of all, cops won't be stopping middle age executives in midtown during rush hour as they call home while running to catch the LIRR. It's just never going to happen. And if it did the mayor would lose those pretty approval numbers he gets overnight.

Instead, what this will lead to is cops hassling young black and hispanic kids at 2am on the phone trying to figure out which club to head to next and when there aren't any cars on the road anyway. They'll get the usual stop and frisk and probably get busted for pot possession (which means they spend 3 or 4 days in Rikers, pay a $90 fine and cost the system a few thousand to process them).

There's a law of unintended consequences that Sen. Kruger needs to learn. This will not stop pedestrian accidents, and the public will learn that quickly. The backlash against anyone who supports this is likely to be strong.

Just like when they tried to make it a crime to have your cell phone ring in a theater, this infringes on people's privacy in ways that nobody is considering yet. Nobody wants to be walking down fifth ave while on the phone and haiving to pause the conversation at every corner. Nor will the cops want to enforce such stupidity, jusy as they don't enforce jaywalking now (which, incidentally, probably leads to more accidents than ipods). Of course, if you are jaywalking with your ipod on, you're really just asking for it.

Anyone who thinks this is a good idea needs to get their head, or at least their common sense, examined. And any minority legislator who supports this will hear about it from their constituents.

by Robert Hornak, Thursday, Feb. 8 | Permalink



Our current elected leaders feel they are smarter than the general public and want to protect us from ourselves. What's going to happen when these laws start to impede construction of necessary public works such as a staircase up Queensborough Bridge from Roosevelt Island? New Yorkers need to start looking at who is in office and why they are there.

by daniel , Saturday, Apr. 7

Posted by daniel
Saturday, Apr. 7 - 1:44 PM